By Chris Kuehl, managing director, Armada Corporate Intelligence
Remember when people could discuss politics in a reasonable tone without resorting to vicious attacks? Political discourse has become increasingly polarized, making reasonable political discussion far less common than it once was.
Yet when it comes to the economy, separating politics from economics is nearly impossible because the two profoundly influence one another. The perspective presented here is rooted in the economic philosophy of Milton Friedman and the Chicago School of Economics, an approach that emphasizes free enterprise and pro-business policies. Beyond that, an assessment of Democrats and Republicans may be William Shakespeare’s quote, “A plague on both your houses.”
There are four key issues at stake that will shape the economic landscape:
- Tax policy
- Regulatory policy
- Trade relations
- Government support
Tax Policy
Taxation is always top of mind, and never more so than when deficits are running at current levels. Bringing down the $2 trillion deficit is not possible without two very unpopular political moves — raising taxes and cutting spending.
For the first time ever, interest payments on the federal debt have climbed above $1 trillion, making debt service the second-largest part of the federal budget, behind only Social Security. There is nothing approaching consensus regarding where that tax revenue will come from. Democrats favor taxing the wealthy, although nobody seems to agree on exactly what that entails, while Republicans appear to favor more “nickel-and-dime” taxes, often described as user fees. Most in politics seem content to avoid the issue altogether. Spending cuts alone will not solve the problem because the bulk of the federal budget is devoted to Social Security, debt service, Medicare, Medicaid and the military, which are considered “sacred cows.”
There have been assertions that economic growth alone will enable the deficit and debt to shrink, but for that to occur, the US economy would need GDP growth exceeding 5% a quarter for at least five consecutive years. That has never happened. The 25-year average GDP growth rate has been 2.5%. Even when the US economy is operating in high gear, GDP rarely exceeds 4% and only for a short time.
Regulatory Policy
Regulation always is a can of worms. Nobody objects to basic regulations that prohibit dangerous practices or outright cheating, but it’s often hard to clearly identify when these practices are taking place. The most consistent objection arises when regulations appear designed to give one group or sector an advantage or to punish a particular set of businesses.
The Code of Federal Regulations is 188,000 pages. Federal agencies publish about 4,000 new regulations every year, and this number doesn’t include regulations that come from states or local communities. It has been estimated that over 40% of those regulations apply to the manufacturing sector, and that compliance costs the sector roughly $240 billion annually. The average annual cost of regulation in the US is $3 trillion, and that translates into $16,000 a year per household.
Not all regulations are bad, but there are regulations that appear superfluous, and many contradict one another. Then there are regulations that simply baffle the mind, such as the Missouri law stating that when two trains encounter one another on the same track, neither shall pass until the other has moved. Uh…what? Both Democrats and Republicans continue to push regulations, albeit different ones in different areas.
Trade Relations
Trade relations and tariffs have been front and center for almost a decade, although there has been a great deal of variety in terms of emphasis. Tariffs have long been deployed to protect some aspect of the domestic economy, but the more common technique has been non-tariff barriers (NTBs), which have served as more permanent regulatory protections. These were once referred to as “infant industry” restrictions. The idea was that emerging industries needed protection from competition until they could stand on their own.
Lately, tariffs have become negotiating tools. Nations use them to encourage or discourage particular actions by their trading partners. The problem from a business perspective is that these tariffs tend to be highly changeable, and that creates havoc in a company’s supply chain. Most business objections to tariff policy come down to the lack of permanence.
There is no time to adjust or react to the changes before tariffs are increased, reduced or removed altogether. Nearly all of the tariffs imposed during the past several years have fallen into this category, creating real chaos in the supply chains. Companies are afraid they will buy at one price due to the tariff, but then the tariff is reduced or eliminated, allowing competitors to buy cheaper.
Government Support
The United States has never had an industrial policy on the same scale as Japan or Europe, but there have long been incentives such as tax breaks, research support and more. Government support can accelerate economic growth. Traditionally, those investments have focused on infrastructure – everything from transportation to energy. There also have been efforts to boost investment in alternative energy, housing and education.
The question now is: What sectors will get that kind of help in the future? Support for electric vehicles has faded, and so has support for alternative energy. Will there be more attention paid to trade schools? Will there be efforts to increase access to rare earth minerals? There are many areas where government money could be directed.
Looking Ahead
Politics can be messy and alienating during an election campaign. The reality is that nearly 80% of likely voters already had made up their minds months ago. Campaigns now focus on getting core supporters to vote and capturing that sliver of undecided voters. After the election, members of Congress ostensibly settle down to business and start working on key economic issues.
Chris Kuehl is managing director of Armada Corporate Intelligence. Armada executives function as trusted strategic advisers to business executives, merging fundamental roots in corporate intelligence gathering, economic forecasting and strategy development. Armada focuses on the market forces bearing down on organizations.
More information: www.armada-intel.com
